Commenting 10 Commandments

What this is

Welcome to the PFB forum, dubbed The Chamber by @DrCCowboy, a brilliant name. It only took us eight years to make it for you guys. You’ll notice that we have five categories that you don’t have to pay for – hoops, football, recruiting other sports and non-sports – and one you have to pay for – our PFB+ category.

The Kyles and other staffers will mostly be in the PFB+ forum, dropping rumors and thoughts on a variety of things, and we’re looking for a few moderators to help us run everything else. We’re excited about what this place could be – what we hope it is, and to watch it grow in the years to come.

How to sign up

If you’re simply looking to sign up for a free account and hang in the free forums, you can go here and join for free. If you want to join PFB+, go to the same link and sign up for under “monthly” or “yearly.”

What are the commenting commandments here?

The internet is both the worst and the best. If you’re reading something called “the rules of engagement” about a blog turned website + forum, you have likely already experienced this. Our slogan around here is “the best OSU news and community,” and we desire for you to experience both.

Doesn’t mean things will always be unicorns named Bullet and pots o’gold, but it does mean we’ve strived in these rules to create a space where we can argue smartly, be professional and genuinely enjoy the company of fellow Pokes.

Here are the 10 commandments …

1. Be a pro: The opposite of this is maybe more helpful … don’t be an amateur.

2. This is a sports bar: The Chamber was created to be a sports bar. When I think of sports bars, I think of hilarious debates about ridiculous things and a lot of fun memories with good friends. I don’t think of brouhahas over politics.

3. Debate the argument, not the person: This is a lot easier when you don’t name-call. If you have to ask if what you’re typing is a personal attack on a writer or commenter, it probably is. Don’t be mean or spiteful. Do be extremely sarcastic.

4. Community matters: It does. And we want this to be a great one. Remember that the person typing into his or her phone is a human being, has a story you don’t know and is probably trying to find a lot of the same things you’re looking for.

5. College kids are college kids: They actually are amateurs. Be fair when you get after them.

6. Rumormill: We’re here for all the rumors.

7. Shutting it down: We’re going to error on the liberal side of keeping threads open and not banning users. You’re all adults. Our rule here is mostly around repeat offenders. If you egregiously and repeatedly violate the spirit of any of these guidelines or if your name is continuously flagged in The Chamber for public comments you make, we reserve the right to make you take a 48-hour break following at least one warning. We will announce publicly that we have suspended users on the first violation and then name who they are on the second and third.

If this continues in the future and you’re ruining a good thing for everyone else, we reserve the right to ban you (if you’ve been around the comments section of our site, Richard Kennedy is the example here). If we ban someone from The Chamber we will write an explanation of why that person was banned.

8. Don’t curse: If you do, it better be really funny because Discourse is going to block it either way.

9. Premium content stays premium: This goes both ways. We have subs to everything so we’ll post anything you want behind the PFB+ wall (The Athletic, Go Pokes etc.) Our ask is that you don’t post our PFB+ stuff on the regular portion of The Chamber (or elsewhere).

10. Threads: We don’t need a thread for every little thing. Most of it can simply go in the 2019 football thread or the 2020 recruiting thread. If you think “should I make a new thread?” the answer is likely no.

11. (Bonus) #Content: We reserve the right to post anything in The Chamber on our website because everyone can see it anyway. If it’s posted in the PFB+ portion of The Chamber, we will ask before we post on the main site.

At the end of the day, this is a sports blog. It was created for a community of folks who love Oklahoma State athletics. It was not created so that peace could be brought to North Korea. We write this often, but perspective, humor and kindness are appreciated. One of our core values here at PFB is kindness, and we expect that from our people as well.

8 Likes

Cheers to The Chamber! Glad to have had a part in naming it. Go Pokes!

1 Like
  1. The University of Oklahoma can go straight to hell
11 Likes

Can they pass go to collect $200?

1 Like

Threads are great.

Rule No. 7 has been updated.

3 Likes

I like it. It’s more comprehensive, which should hopefully stave off the borderline behavior.

@kyleporterCBS Not sure where to ask this so I will ask here.

Have you ever been on the CFB Reddit site? I am wondering if there is a way built into this site system to add flairs to our nametags? I have snipped a photo below as an example. I think the flairs could be our degree, graduation year, favorite sport, intramural team, greek house, or whatever.

1 Like

You can do this, but it might be limited to groups (i.e. all of our PFB+ folks could have the same flair or something like that). I read through this for a bit, but you might take a deep dive to see if it can be individually accomplished.

1 Like

Gotcha, I will let you know if I come up with something. (If you’re interested, don’t want to bother you, if not)

Please do!

Alright, I think I have some answers. First, looks like groups would be the only way to get this done on discourse, currently. According to the snip I show below, admins are the only ones who can create groups but can assign a “group leader” to handle running the group after it is created. (More info below snip)

Next, the group can be shown as a flair after the username, however, only one flair can be shown at a time. A normal user would have to join a group, and then assign it as their primary group in order for it to show up as a flair. If you read the post AND first comment in the link below, the poster explains a similar circumstance needing deeper groups within their discourse community and asking whether his users can show off their subcommunities with badges/flairs. The first comment describes how groups can make this happen. In our use case, I don’t see us needing “subcommunities” per se, but more simply just some characterizing traits to bring more interest to the forum and legitimacy to the individual users.

Since we’re all about shaming here, I feel like I should be on a wall of fame (shame) for receiving the first ban.

3 Likes

Not trying to bump this convo but found another example to add to the convo. The text circled in the snip below is how a user’s primary “Group” would show up after their username. I think for our case the text shown as “team” below could be something like, “Class of 2016” or “Beta Theta Pi” or whatever, users could get creative.

Downside to this idea is that it looks like the groups can only be created by admin if what I am skimming through is accurate to date.

Edit: This is just to add to my post above, where I got into some more detail

2 Likes

I added that little plus badge to all PFB+ folks. Playing around with it right now, but it’s kinda cool.

I like it. I think the admin group could have a special image to draw more attention to Boone, Carson, etc. Maybe a cowboy hat or orange boots. Something dumb and cheesy for sure. Orange Maple leaf perhaps? :joy:

1 Like

@kyleporterCBS also, are you experiencing a bug where the replies aren’t really working? I’ve had it happen several times where I click reply, the reply post comes up correctly but after I hit post, it doesn’t actually post as a reply.